Young & Hinckley's contradictory statements: featuring Rafael Arevalo

What was Brigham Young's View of Plural Marriage?

Yes, Brigham Young did discuss plural marriage quite extensively and was known to make strong statements about its importance during his time as Prophet. The quote you mentioned is similar to one attributed to him, where he talked about the necessity of accepting all doctrines revealed through the Prophet, including plural marriage, to avoid being damned.

However, it's always good to consider the context of historical statements: they were often specific to the time, circumstances, and challenges facing the Church and its members.

About the Quotes -

The quote referring to is indeed a strong statement from Brigham Young. It is recorded as:

"Now if any of you will deny the plurality of wives and continue to do so, I promise that you will be damned."

This statement reflects the intensity of Brigham Young's advocacy for plural marriage during the period when it was practiced by the Church.

About the Source -

The quote from Brigham Young regarding plural marriage can be found in his discourses, which were often recorded and compiled by those attending his speeches. Specifically, this one appears in the "Journal of Discourses," a collection of public sermons by early leaders of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. This particular quote is from Volume 3, given on July 14, 1855. I have provide a complete talk of this address to help you check out what's all about. Link Here

The "Journal of Discourses" includes many sermons and addresses from the early days of the Church, though they are not considered official scripture. They do, however, provide insight into the historical context and teachings of that era. If you're researching Church history, the "Journal of Discourses" is a valuable resource, but it's also good to cross-reference with other sources or Church-published material for a fuller understanding.

Okay so moving on, in regards to this statement where everybody is trying use it a main source of Criticisms while the context says something different as how Brigham Young addresses his discourses. Below was part of his statement you may also see on the link -

It is not through lust that men and women are to practice this doctrine, but it is to be observed upon righteous principles; and, if men and women would pay attention to those instructions, I would promise, in the name of the Lord, that you would never find them lustful in their dispositions, and you might watch them as closely as you pleased.

Plurality of wives is not designed to afflict you nor me, but is purposed for our exaltation in the kingdoms of God. If any man had asked me what was my choice when Joseph revealed that doctrine, provided that it would not diminish my glory, I would have said, “Let me have but one wife;” not because it is not a great comfort to me to have children, but if I have not children, I know them not.

Some of these my brethren know what my feelings were at the time Joseph revealed the doctrine; I was not desirous of shrinking from any duty, nor of failing in the least to do as I was commanded, but it was the first time in my life that I had desired the grave, and I could hardly get over it for a long time. And when I saw a funeral, I felt to envy the corpse its situation, and to regret that I was not in the coffin, knowing the toil and labor that my body would have to undergo; and I have had to examine myself, from that day to this, and watch my faith, and carefully meditate, lest I should be found desiring the grave more than I ought to do.

Brigham Young’s statement regarding plural marriage in his July 14, 1855, discourse was made in a period when the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints was under significant scrutiny and pressure both from within and outside the church regarding its practice of plural marriage. This practice was publicly acknowledged in 1852, and Brigham Young, as a staunch defender of the principle, addressed it numerous times.

In his discourses, including the one from July 14, 1855, Brigham Young aimed to reaffirm and reinforce the commitment of Church members to all doctrines the Lord had revealed to the Prophet Joseph Smith, including plural marriage. He often used strong language to emphasize the seriousness with which these teachings should be received and the consequences of rejecting them.

During this time, plural marriage was seen as both a commandment from God and a test of faith for many Church members. Brigham Young and other Church leaders taught that strict adherence to all of God's commandments was essential for salvation, which is reflected in his forceful statements about the doctrine of plural marriage.

This context underscores the complexity of historical Church practices and doctrines, reflecting the challenges Church leaders and members faced in adhering to their faith while also dealing with external opposition and internal uncertainties.

So, to sum it up. Just as a normal person like you and me, Brigham Young didn't even like the practice, but it was reveal during their time in which he simply abide, it was practiced upon the principles of righteousness which means every marriage were performed as part of Covenant. Everyone during their time were aware of the practice and it's widely accepted in Latter-day Saint's Circle. It's not actually an issue until the Government Presented Monogamy as standard practice. Yes it's kinda awkward in our days just as the people of old like the patriarchs.

Gordon B. Hinckley's Points of View.

Did Gordon B Hinckley says I condemn it? Yes as practice and here's more of it below

Gordon B. Hinckley emphasized that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints does not practice polygamy and that it is not a part of the Church's teachings today. Here's one specific quote from an interview he did with Larry King in 1998:

• Larry King: "Is polygamy legal? Do you condemn it?" 
• Gordon B. Hinckley: "I condemn it. Yes, as a practice, because I think it is not doctrinal. It is not legal. And this Church takes the position that we will abide by the law."

President Hinckley was very clear that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints no longer practices polygamy and condemns it as it is both illegal and not part of the Church’s doctrine.

About the Show -
The interview with President Gordon B. Hinckley you're referring to took place on "Larry King Live." Larry King was a famous talk show host, and this particular episode aired in 1998. President Hinckley was there to discuss various aspects of the Church and its teachings, and he addressed several important topics, including the Church's stance on polygamy.

About the Dialogue of the Show -

• Polygamy: President Hinckley firmly stated that the Church does not practice polygamy and that it is against the law. He made it clear that the Church adheres to the legal standards of the land.
• Humanitarian Efforts: He talked about the Church's extensive humanitarian efforts around the world, emphasizing the importance of service and charity.
• Commitment to Christ: President Hinckley reaffirmed the Church’s commitment to Jesus Christ and its Christian foundation.
• Growth of the Church: He discussed the rapid growth of the Church worldwide, highlighting the increasing number of members and new temples being built.
• Media Perceptions: President Hinckley touched on how the Church is often misunderstood or misrepresented in the media and how the Church strives to be more transparent and open.

In conclusion, members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints uphold the principle of continuous revelation, recognizing that each era, or dispensation, has unique prophetic and spiritual needs. This belief fosters an adaptive faith that remains attuned to the specific guidance and directives issued by contemporary prophets, following the precedent set by scriptural teachings. Consequently, the doctrines and practices of the Church can evolve in response to ongoing revelation, ensuring alignment with God's will under changing circumstances and challenges. This flexibility underscores the Church’s commitment to divine guidance across different historical contexts.

Rafael Arevalo uses the same Meme for his Criticism,
But never knew what was it all about.